Why is f&g against the point system?

Question:

Every year the same people that have drawn multiple times draw again. There are those of us that have never drawn. Everyone knows that some people are just very lucky and there are others that never win anything. Why is fish and game so dead set against evening up the chances.
I was also told by more than one fish and game representative that if you do not fill out a harvest report your draw is pulled if this is true do you refund the application fee?

Answer:

The Idaho Fish and Game Commission has seriously considered point systems in the past, most recently in 2005 and 2010. In 2005, the Commission adopted a point system contingent on the Idaho Legislature passing a law that allowed the Fish and Game Department to charge a small surcharge on each application to cover the cost of implementing the system. The legislature debated a bill, but eventually rejected it and the point system was not implemented. In 2009, the legislature passed a law that allowed the Department to charge no more than $4.50 per controlled hunt application to fund a point system should the Commission implement one. In 2010, the Fish and Game Department proposed implementing a bonus point system (very similar to Nevada’s).

Ultimately, the Commission failed to accept the proposal. The Commission cited several reasons for not adopting a point system, including: 1) adding increased complexity to the licensing system, 2) impact on casual/youth hunters that would be disadvantaged by a point system, and 3) responding to substantive public perception that the Department was proposing a point system simply to increase revenues. Additionally, comment received during the public scoping process indicated broad public disagreement on the specifics of any single system. Areas of disagreement: bonus points vs. preference points, whether a point-only option should be implemented, which hunts or what species should the system apply to, and whether a point system should be mandatory or voluntary.

A report prepared for the commission is available at http://fishandgame.idaho.gov/public/licenses/controlledHunts.

Your controlled hunt application is not rejected if you do not submit your hunter harvest report.  If you have any questions concerning a bonus point system or the controlled hunt application process, please contact your nearest Fish and Game office.